Disbanding NYPD counterterrorism unit will embolden criminals, former prosecutor warns
Saritha Komatireddy warned that disbanding the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group would leave the very people it works to protect more vulnerable to violence. “None of this is to say that every protest has been handled perfectly. … But dismantling the entire apparatus creates a violence free-for-all. That is a step too far,” she wrote.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s decision to disband the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG) will make the city less safe, former federal terrorism prosecutor Saritha Komatireddy argued in a Nov. 16 op-ed for The Free Press.
Komatireddy, the 2026 Republican nominee for New York Attorney General, pointed to her experience prosecuting ISIS fighters in Brooklyn, where she served as a federal prosecutor for more than a decade.
“A crowd is an opportunity for people who mean to do harm,” she wrote. “I saw firsthand how protests can be infiltrated by criminals and terrorists who use the cover of peaceful demonstrators to carry out violence.”
Komatireddy’s warning followed Mamdani’s Nov. 16 announcement that the city would disband the Strategic Response Group (SRG), a specialized NYPD unit that handles crowd management and counterterrorism. Under Mamdani’s plan, dialogue and de-escalation will be the focus of the city’s protest response, as Zeale News previously reported. An unarmed civilian division without arrest powers and a separate NYPD team will lead that effort. A new patrol division will manage crowds and make arrests when necessary, and the NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau will take over the SRG’s counterterrorism duties.
Komatireddy cited the shooting of two Co-op City public safety officers during a wellness check in the Bronx just hours after Mamdani’s announcement.
“The man who shot them didn’t want to have a dialogue. Neither do terrorists,” she wrote. “That leaves the backup patrol cops. They may receive crowd-management training, but they will be hamstrung with new restrictions when facing down criminals who know that resisting arrest and assaulting a cop are no longer prosecuted with seriousness. … We are trading a tested unit for an untested promise.”
Komatireddy also warned those intent on violence could see the decision as an opportunity to act.
“The most immediate effect of the decision to disband the SRG is the message it sends—it emboldens those determined to wreak havoc on our streets,” Komatireddy wrote. “Criminals will be more likely to commit violence knowing that there will be no one there equipped to stop them.”
Among those Komatireddy said stood to lose protection were peaceful protesters and people attending religious services. She pointed to attacks on houses of worship as a source of concern for Jewish, Christian, Hindu, and Muslim New Yorkers.
“The government has an obligation to protect New Yorkers’ First Amendment right to worship with equal force as our First Amendment right to speak, assemble, and protest,” she wrote. “Albany and the City Council have authorized buffer zones around houses of worship, but a buffer zone is only as strong as the officers ready to enforce it. When the Little Rock Nine walked into Central High School in 1957, it was the 101st Airborne that held the line, not dialogue specialists.”
Komatireddy pointed to the toll of looting in 2020, when about 450 businesses were damaged or had merchandise stolen. Many of the hardest hit were small, minority-owned businesses, she wrote.
Komatireddy said violence at protests could also affect commuters and bystanders, including “the workers who miss their shifts, the delivery drivers with docked pay, the kids stranded because their parents missed pickup, the patients that an ambulance can’t reach.”
Komatireddy predicted that officials would downplay the role their decision to disband the SRG could play in fueling violence.
“You can almost picture the press releases: Officials will condemn the inevitable violence that follows, calling it ‘random’ and ‘senseless’ when it is actually predictable and preventable,” she wrote. “As always, it’s the innocent, hardworking New Yorkers who will pay the price.”










Comments