Politics

Report: Young conservatives soured on GOP over weak immigration, foreign worker crackdown

College Republicans at Clemson say they voted Democratic or stayed home to protest Trump’s Iran war and that the administration has not gone far enough on deportations.

DU
David Uebbing
· 3 min read
Report: Young conservatives soured on GOP over weak immigration, foreign worker crackdown
Republican U.S. Senate nominee Sen. Darline Graham (R-SC) leaves the stage during a campaign rally with U.S. President Donald Trump at T. Ed Garrison Arena at Clemson University on October 21, 2026 in Pendleton, South Carolina. (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

Some young conservatives who voted Democratic in protest or skipped South Carolina’s Senate race Nov. 3 say immigration enforcement was the Republican Party’s one winning issue and that the Trump administration did not go far enough, according to a feature in New York Magazine.

Advertisement

“We had one winning issue, and that was immigration,” Jane Kihne, the 22-year-old co-chair of the Clemson University College Republicans, told the magazine. Overall, exit polling showed that 14% of voters ranked immigration as the most important issue facing the country. 

The magazine spoke with club members at a Nov. 5 meeting, two days after Democrat Annie Andrews defeated Republican Sen. Darline Graham, the first Democrat elected to the U.S. Senate from the state since 1998, according to the South Carolina Daily Gazette. 

Several members said they voted for Andrews, or would have if they voted, as a protest and not because they like her policies. Their main grievance was Trump’s Iran war, but the magazine said every member it spoke with also cited immigration.

The main issues that seem to be underlying the angst about immigration among these college students were tied to a tough job market and concerns about cultural shifts. 

The students had been drifting toward Nick Fuentes, a broadcaster the magazine describes as openly antisemitic, who urged his followers to vote Democratic in the midterms to punish Republicans for not delivering on immigration and a more nationalistic approach to governance.

Conservative analysts argue that immigration enforcement was not to blame for the defeat. Immigration was the most important issue for 13% of voters, behind the economy and the state of democracy, in the Fox News Voter Poll, with 89% of those voters concerned about immigration backing Republicans. The poll also found Republicans held a 3-point edge on immigration, the only issue on which they led, though most voters said enforcement had gone too far.

Trump himself said in a 60 Minutes interview that deportation policy “might be too tough.” Among young voters, the Harvard Youth Poll conducted Sept. 30 to Oct. 7 found 67% of young Republicans supported increased deportations, but Democrats led Republicans by 15 points on trust over immigration enforcement among registered voters ages 18 to 29.

To put their grievances in context, though, voters aged 18-29 only comprise about 10% of the national electorate, and those identifying as conservative are roughly 40% of that age grouping. 

Sohrab Ahmari, one of the leading intellectuals on the so-called new right, described what he sees as a winning formula for the magazine. He believes conservatives should have “hawkish immigration policy, pro-labor economic populism, [and] foreign-policy restraint.” 

But Ahmari says that the Trump administration failed to introduce pro-labor measures and its war with Iran was clearly not an exercise in restraint. “I would argue that the most responsible version of the New Right, it’s either been vindicated or not even tested,” Ahmari told the magazine.

In the aftermath of the election drubbing, Trump named Stephen Miller, the architect of his immigration policy, his new chief of staff on Nov. 6. 

The administration also proposed a Treasury rule on Nov. 17 letting banks ask about immigration status in financial transactions suspected of involving fraud and the Labor Department proposed an overhaul of green card hiring.

Comments