Politics

ANALYSIS | Beyond the billions: The human toll of welfare fraud

Widespread welfare fraud harms American taxpayers and the Americans who rely on the programs fraudsters target.

SM
S.A. McCarthy
· 6 min read
ANALYSIS | Beyond the billions: The human toll of welfare fraud
(frank333 / Shutterstock.com)

Over the past year, welfare fraud has emerged as a key plank in President Donald Trump’s platform of restoring prosperity and integrity to the American people and safeguarding American resources. While headlines have largely centered on the Trump administration’s efforts to identify, curb, and prevent fraud, very little has been said of the real cost of widespread welfare fraud.

Advertisement

The dollar amount alone is staggering. According to the “fraud ledger” launched earlier this year by the White House Task Force to Eliminate Fraud, the Trump administration has uncovered more than $260 billion in fraud since January 2025. All of that money comes from American taxpayers, whose federal tax dollars support welfare programs either administered by the federal government or, more commonly, funded by the federal government but administered by state governments.

>> White House launches fraud ledger tracking nearly $230B in estimated fraud <<

The fraud ledger also tracks Trump administration actions that have prevented an estimated $72 billion in fraud annually and indictments and settlements to “claw back” nearly $60 billion in stolen taxpayer funds so far. The Trump administration is the first to crack down on welfare fraud and the widespread abuse and theft of taxpayer dollars so strictly, but the lax approach to the problem by previous generations means that tens and even hundreds of billions of hard-earned American dollars are lost forever.

Putting a price tag on fraud

According to the Government Accountability Office (GAO), improper payments of federal taxpayer dollars amounted to roughly $186 billion in fiscal year 2025, an increase over 2024. Nearly half (approximately 40%) of those improper payments came from welfare programs. Medicaid accounted for more than $37 billion in improper payments, the earned income tax credit (EITC) for more than $21 billion, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) for more than $10 billion, supplemental security income for more than $7 billion — all over the course of a single fiscal year.

As if the mismanagement of $186 billion in taxpayer dollars is not bad enough, the GAO reported that the volume of improper payments it identified does not “represent the full extent of government-wide improper payments.” In some programs, improper payments below a certain dollar amount are not subject to mandatory reporting requirements; for example, improper SNAP payments below $58 are not required to be reported, but these smaller dollar amounts account for more than one third (38%) of improper SNAP payments.

The overwhelming majority (73%) of improper payments identified by the GAO were concentrated in just five programs: Medicare, Medicaid, EITC, SNAP, and the Shuttered Venue Operators Grant program.

Advertisement

The costs of improper payments and fraud are borne by the American taxpayer. According to a Zeale News analysis of federal taxpayer data, improper payments in federally funded programs cost each American taxpayer approximately $1,110 throughout fiscal year 2025.

“Those figures should not all be called ‘fraud.’ Improper payments are in large part due to administrative errors and other erroneous payments,” Rachel Sheffield, a research fellow in welfare and family policy at the Heritage Foundation’s Grover M. Hermann Center for the Federal Budget, told Zeale News.

“But those figures also understate the broader integrity problem because many types of actual fraud are not captured by improper-payment estimates. That includes identity theft, provider billing fraud, and SNAP trafficking,” she continued. “Ultimately, every fraudulent or improper payment comes out of taxpayers’ pockets. Getting a handle on the amount of fraud in means-tested programs is difficult because it isn't measured well.”

Meanwhile, those defrauding taxpayer-funded programs have used their ill-gotten fortunes to fund lives of luxury and extravagance. Defendants in Ohio charged with billing Medicaid for medical procedures that were never performed bought some 14 high-end vehicles, including a McLaren 570S sportscar, a Bentley Bentayga, a Jaguar, a Maserati, six Mercedes cars, and other costly automobiles.

An Arizona defendant who was charged with billing federal funding programs for addiction services that his supposed “clients” (toddlers and dead people) could not receive used his loot to buy a mansion that he later sold for an estimated $6 million, nearly four dozen luxury vehicles, and multiple Rolex watches. 

A defendant in Florida who pleaded guilty to running a scheme billing Medicare for $42 million in cancer testing that patients did not need or want purchased a $600,000 yacht and a number of expensive cars. Federal authorities seized the yacht and were able to reclaim roughly $1 million in cash, but more than $40 million stolen from American taxpayers was lost irrevocably.

>> Trump administration halts $112M in Medicare and Medicaid payments to Minnesota over fraud <<

Fraud is not a victimless crime

Of course, the reason that American taxpayers fund welfare and related programs is for the benefit of their fellow Americans who cannot afford the care that they need. Fraud not only robs Americans of their tax dollars but also deprives those who rely on taxpayer-funded programs of the care and resources that, in many cases, they need or rely on.

Advertisement

When Lynn Ianni needed Medicare to fund her physical therapy after a shoulder injury, she was initially denied coverage — because her Medicare number was used to enroll her in hospice care in Los Angeles, according to a report from The Los Angeles Times. It took months — and phone calls to multiple Medicare representatives, eventually reaching the Senior Medicare Patrol — before Ianni was issued a new Medicare card.

More than 5,500 women in the Memphis area were exposed to potential infection over a five-year period because gynecologist Sanjeev Kumar reused the same 200 hysteroscopes to perform more than 15,000 hysteroscopies, billing Medicare and Medicaid $41 million for the new hysteroscopes that he never used. Earlier this year, Kumar was sentenced to 20 years in prison.

“If we allow doctors to bilk Medicare and Medicaid to pad their profits by performing unsupported medical procedures with filthy devices — each and every American taxpayer eats the cost,” U.S. Attorney D. Michael Dunavant said in a statement. “But the harm is most felt by the victim-patients who deserved better, and the American women on Medicare and Medicaid are entitled to quality care. Kumar’s blatant disregard for his patients’ health has led to his conviction on multiple federal charges.”

Kumar’s former patients reported serious pains, likely infections, and even linked his lack of proper care to miscarriages, according to WZTV Nashville, a FOX affiliate. 

Single mother of four Angel Haskins in Lynchburg, Virginia, relied on SNAP to help feed her children. The day that her benefits loaded on Jan. 4, 2025, a scammer stole the $1,158 Haskins would use to feed her children. When she attempted to buy food for her four children, her SNAP account had only $0.66 left.

“I cried. I cried. Because I don't know what to do. That barely gets us through the month as is, so it's very devastating,” she said of her experience.

“The kids, they don’t know what’s going on. They’re innocent. We’re just struggling to make it work,” Haskins said. “It’s definitely hard. You can’t make ends meet. Sometimes I can just make ramen noodles for the kids, that’s all we can afford.”

Haskins’ SNAP case manager told her that her funds could not be replaced, leaving the family without money for food for the month.

“Fraud steals taxpayer money away from their intended purpose and forces agencies to spend time and money investigating and correcting these cases. And in some fraud schemes, the intended beneficiary is much more directly harmed,” Sheffield observed of the real-world impact of fraud. “Criminals can steal SNAP benefits from a recipient’s EBT account, for example, taking benefits away that are intended for low-income households.”

Matt Weidinger, a senior fellow and Rowe Scholar in opportunity and mobility studies at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), told Zeale News that the mass defrauding of American taxpayer dollars kicked into high gear with the government’s response to COVID-19, which involved extremely low oversight over increasingly high amounts of money.

“Expanded unemployment benefits during the pandemic (which bear many of the marks of welfare programs — funded with general revenues, paid even to those without prior work, and paid in amounts unrelated to prior earnings) offer a notable recent example,” he said, pointing to the ease with which fraudsters could steal federal funds.

“Massive amounts have been lost to fraud,” he added. “Again, the pandemic experience with unemployment benefits provide a sense of the massive scale and cost. Less lost to fraud means lower deficits over time — reducing already-existing pressure for tax hikes and spending cuts.”

>> Vance highlights billions in fraud uncovered by White House task force <<

Comments