U.S.

Minnesota fathers sue over education tax benefits excluding curricula guided by faith

Two Christian families say the state’s K-12 Education Credit and Subtraction programs unconstitutionally disqualify expenses for instruction that involves religious beliefs.

DU
David Uebbing
· 3 min read
Minnesota fathers sue over education tax benefits excluding curricula guided by faith
The Minnesota Judicial Branch building, which houses the Minnesota Tax Court, in St. Paul, Minnesota. (Photo by Aaron of L.A. Photography/Shutterstock)

Two Minnesota fathers, represented by Alliance Defending Freedom and the Upper Midwest Law Center, sued the state’s revenue commissioner Nov. 16 over a law that disqualifies expenses involving teaching religious tenets from two education tax benefits programs otherwise open to most parents.

Advertisement

“Parents, not the government, have the right to direct how their children are raised and educated,” said Kate Anderson, an Alliance Defending Freedom senior counsel who directs its Center for Parental Rights.

Anderson explained that the suit was filed because “Minnesota can’t offer all parents a tax break and then exclude families like the Colestocks and Osburns, who choose to educate their kids fully in line with their faith. We’re urging the court to uphold the fundamental right of Minnesota families to choose Christian education for their kids while receiving much-needed financial help from the state—aid that is available to all other families.”

Both benefits exclude books, materials, fees, and tuition “used in the teaching of religious tenets, doctrines, or worship,” according to the complaint. The plaintiffs say they cannot claim the benefits because doing so would require them to state that their children’s education does not include religious instruction. Both fathers say that they teach every subject from a religious perspective.

The suit, Colestock v. Marquart, names Revenue Commissioner Paul Marquart and was filed in the Minnesota Tax Court. The case comes against the backdrop of several clashes that have made their way to the U.S. Supreme Court over the last decade and whose rulings have significantly shifted the legal landscape surrounding the interaction of schools, churches, and ministries with the state.

The complaint cites three key decisions the court has issued: Carson v. Makin, Espinoza v. Montana Dept. of Revenue, and Trinity Lutheran v. Comer. 

“Once Minnesota decides to subsidize education expenses,” the lawsuit argues referencing those cases, “it ‘cannot disqualify some’ recipients ‘solely because they are religious.’” 

The legal challenge is aimed at the state’s K-12 Education Subtraction and Education Credit programs, both of which help offset the cost of tutoring, textbooks, instructional materials, and enrichment programs such as music lessons. 

The Education Subtraction program reduces the amount of taxable income for qualifying expenses by up to $1,625 per child in kindergarten through grade 6 and $2,500 per child in grades 7 through 12. The Education Credit program allows families to reduce the amount they owe in taxes by up to 75% of qualifying expenses with a maximum of $1,500 per child but only for filers below the $70,000 annual income threshold.

Advertisement

Nathan Colestock, a pastor and part-time head of Valor Classical Academy, has four children, two of whom are school age. His family’s income is below the $70,000 cap for the maximum Credit, the complaint says, and he expects to spend about $700 on curricula and materials beyond tuition. 

Joseph Osburn, a technology director at a Christian ministry, has six children. His income is too high for the Credit, but he qualifies for the Subtraction program and has not claimed it for the past three tax years, according to the complaint. 

The suit argues that the state’s exclusion violates the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, the Minnesota Constitution’s guarantee of freedom of conscience, and the Fourteenth Amendment’s protection of parents’ right to direct their children’s education. 

In an interesting legal twist, the complaint asserts that the Tax Court lacks original authority to decide constitutional questions, and so the plaintiffs filed a motion asking it to refer those questions to the Minnesota District Court. They also served notice of the constitutional challenge to the state attorney general.

The Minnesota Department of Revenue declined to comment, according to Alpha News. Zeale News reported in September that the Alliance Defending Freedom has also sued a Washington state school district on behalf of a father who was denied opt-outs from LGBT-related instruction.

Comments