Op-ed: How Mamdani could win families back to New York City public schools
The New York Post editorial urged Mamdani to back gifted programs and selective magnet schools as families continue to compete for seats at the city’s top public schools.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani could reverse the city’s decline in public school enrollment by raising academic standards, the New York Post editorial board argued in a Nov. 19 opinion piece.
Enrollment in the city’s Department of Education schools has fallen by nearly 200,000 students since the 2013–14 school year, the editorial noted.
“The latest city Department of Education data show its schools bleeding over 10% of their population in a single year — a collapse faster than demographics can explain,” the board wrote.
They pointed to school quality as a reason for the enrollment decline.
“The problem is that the product is terrible, as the system ignores parents and kids to serve the toxic trifecta of greedy unions, radical ideologues, and venal political patronage,” the board wrote. “The system’s good schools aren’t seeing enrollment drops, but a crush of families trying for admission.”
The editorial also took aim at the state law that limits class sizes in New York City public schools, days after the Post reported that the city had surpassed its target for meeting those limits.
“But the lefty ‘reformers’ keep trying to destroy those good schools, warring on admissions standards and paying lip service to lunacy like the state class-size law — a teacher-employment scheme that merely pretends that smaller classes are vital to success when the reality is that the city’s good schools have larger classes than the failing ones,” they wrote.
The editorial singled out Mamdani’s stance on selective high schools.
“Give Mamdani this much: As an alum of one of them, he’s refused to join the war on the city’s selective high schools,” it read.
“To save the whole system, though, he’d have to embrace much more that his fellow progressives hate: Gifted & Talented programs, screened magnet schools, standardized testing, and even actually teaching algebra to qualified 8th graders,” the editorial continued.
Asked about the enrollment decline, Mamdani cited “declining birth rates,” federal “immigration policies,” and “the affordability crisis,” according to the Post.
“Well, the drop does include few illegal migrants enrolled without the Biden open-borders policy, and a drop in birth rates matters, too — but affordability shouldn’t much matter when the schools are tuition-free,” the editorial continued.
The Post also weighed the role of early childhood programs in school enrollment after Mamdani and Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul launched 2-K, the city’s free child care program for two-year-olds, in September.
“For now, preschool and ‘universal child care’ can fill up some empty public-school space, but unless the K-12 schools turn around, those kids will toddle away once they leave toddlerhood,” the board wrote.
The Post questioned whether Mamdani would push for higher academic standards.
“Providing a reliably great public-school education would be huge for making New York City more affordable,” the board continued, “but don’t expect this mayor to have the courage to do it.”









Comments