What is male leadership? From exes to relatives, I’ve seen—and lived through—the damage caused when men reject their natural call to leadership.

Some doubt they have what it takes, so they hide. Others misuse their authority for selfish gain. The results are always the same: chaos, mistrust, and emotional fallout.

But what does true masculinity look like in action?

Reading Wild at Heart by John Eldredge, one insight stood out to me: masculinity is bestowed from man to man. As a woman, I know I can only speak to part of this journey. So I asked the men in my life—the ones who consistently show up—for insight.

Here’s what they had to say.

Adobe Stock

Know yourself to lead others

Self-awareness isn’t a buzzword; it’s the bedrock of leadership. It means being able to name your emotions, understand your tendencies, and know your strengths—and yes, your flaws too.

When you have clarity within yourself, you're much more equipped to lead others with stability. If you’re in turmoil, how can you steer the ship for your crew?

The sooner you accept that you’re imperfect, the sooner you can stop fearing mistakes and start learning from them. When you know who you are—and Whose you are—imposter syndrome loses its grip. You’ll realize leadership isn’t about fearlessness, but about acting with courage despite fear.

“Being able to accept that you are not perfect means you move on from your mistakes faster. Learning to laugh at yourself helps!”
- Noah N. 

Try this: Talk with a mentor or trusted friend about one success this week—and one place you’ve fallen short.

Adobe Stock

Choose compassion over control

Not the soft, sentimental kind. Real compassion means gut-level commitment to the well-being of those you're responsible for.

Whether you’re a father, a brother, or a team lead, your job isn’t to dominate—it’s to serve. Leadership is never about control. It’s about shaping others for the better, through presence, interest, and encouragement.

This means being willing to learn—about people, topics, and experiences that fall outside your comfort zone. Great leaders are curious. They can talk with anyone about anything because they care to connect.

Try this: Do one act of service this week for a friend or family member. Ask nothing in return.

“I often find myself stepping into a “big brother” or even father-figure role, not out of superiority, but out of love. I refer to students as “my kids” at times– not to belittle, but because I care for someone brand new to the world.” 
- Angel V

Adobe Stock

Be bold, not brutal

Assertiveness isn’t aggression. It’s the courage to speak truth with the right tone, at the right time.

Real leaders correct without humiliating. They hold people accountable while preserving their dignity. Assertiveness without compassion turns into cruelty—and that kind of leadership breeds resentment, not respect.

Equally important: the best leaders accept correction. They’re not too proud to be taught or too insecure to admit they’re wrong.

Try this: Go to an event or try a new activity on your own. Build inner confidence without needing to perform.

Adobe Stock

Follow through with consistency

Leadership demands commitment—especially to your word. It means showing up, following through, and standing by your standards, even when it's inconvenient.

The people around you need to know they can count on you. That consistency builds trust and earns respect. Without it, even the best intentions fall flat.

It sounds simple. It isn’t. True commitment takes self-discipline, sacrifice, and courage.

“Fasting in any sense builds self-denial. Doing hard things and seeing them through to the end takes grit.” 
- Elliot S.

Try this: Block out time this week to invest in a habit—whether it’s exercise, a hobby, or prayer. Then stick to it.

Adobe Stock

The sacred power of showing up

When a man leads with authenticity—without letting the role define his worth—his leadership becomes something sacred. It’s not about ego. It’s about service, integrity, and legacy.

You don’t have to be perfect. You just have to show up—with courage, care, and conviction.