Americans Stopped Dressing Up. Here's Why.
We went from suits and Sunday best to Cookie Monster pants. Erika traces the great undressing of America from fast fashion and boomer rebellion to the corporate push for Casual Fridays. Just what DOES our obsession with comfort and quantity say about our culture and ourselves?
What if your phone plan paid your favorite charity to save America? Switch to Charity Mobile and BUY the way you BELIEVE! charitymobile.com
Promo code: LOOPCAST
Transcript
Read the full transcriptAuto-generated · 2,572 words
Look at vintage reels of Americans out and about from the 1930s. One thing stands out. Even in the throes of the Great Depression, everyone is dressed to impress. For men, suits, hats, and shiny shoes. For women, tailored dresses, hats, and gloves. But today, people no longer dress up for restaurants or theater or travel, and certainly not for Walmart. Pajamas and Uggs, sports bras and yoga pants are everywhere, and don't even get me started on whatever this is. At a normie American office, even business casual has deteriorated from slacks and a blazer to jeans and a t-shirt.
At the same time, it's easier than ever to find clothing. In the 19th century, American women owned an average of 20 to 30 garments, including those infamous corsets. Today, we own 100 to 200 garments. From the early 1900s to today, the amount Americans spend on clothing has been a rapidly shrinking percentage of our income. Clothing is more affordable and accessible than ever before, yet instead of dressing up, we put on cookie monster pants. Why did Americans stop dressing up? What does wearing underwear as outerwear say about our interior lives as a culture?
And what is the real cause behind the uglification of modern clothing? But before we get into that, first, this episode is brought to you by Charity Mobile. Now, you are probably watching this video on your phone, and if you switch to Charity Mobile, your phone company will actually be building a culture of life. 5% of your monthly plan price is going to go to your choice of a pro-life, pro-family charity, and over the last 30 years, that has added up to millions of dollars from Charity Mobile to organizations that are Actually making a difference.
Charity Mobile has never raised their mobile plan prices in all of that time, and all of the plans start at under $50 before taxes and surcharges, even the unlimited plan. And if you're worried about coverage, it's the same as all the major carriers. Plus, and this cannot be underestimated, there is a friendly pro-life customer service team that is based right here in the United States. And just for you, Deep Watchers, Charity Mobile is running a special promotion through February 2nd. New customers can use promo code LOOPcast to get a free phone with every new line, plus free activation, free shipping, and a free solar-powered bank while the supplies last.
So, to get started, visit CharityMobile.com and use promo code LOOPcast. And now, back to those Cookie Monster pants. In 1885, Irish writer and social critic Oscar Wilde wrote an essay on the philosophy of dress for the New York Tribune. He took brutal aim at the American fashion industry. What is fashion, really? A fashion is merely a form of ugliness so absolutely unbearable that we have to alter it every six months. If clothing was beautiful, well-constructed, and practical, he said, It would remain unchanged in law and principle for many hundreds of years, which, in fact, it did for ordinary people right up until about Wilde's time.
Until then, most clothing was made in the home, stitched by hand or, for those who could afford it, by a tailor. In the 1880s, rapid industrialization brought the West its first foray into fast fashion. Industrial cutting, sewing, and pressing machines Made rapid production possible, as did a vast army of newly arrived immigrant seamstresses who sewed for hours at a time in America's new sweatshops. The money was rolling in. Wilde was unimpressed. He said, The amount of money that is spent every year in America on dress is something almost fabulous.
It is something quite out of proportion to the splendor of modern dress, and that its reason must be looked for. Not in the magnificence of the apparel, but rather in that unhealthy necessity for change which fashion imposes on its beautiful and misguided votaries. In other words, the industry saw a goldmine and started digging. Size standardization, seasonal fashion updates, and mass production were the key.
Standardized clothing came very quickly for men. During the Civil War, factories had already collected of tens of thousands of soldiers. This enabled Gilded Age clothing factories to develop a standard sizing for men rapidly. Even women's fashion, though, with its endless capacity for complicating everything, started to simplify by the 1890s. The changes were partly driven by culture. Women were working or organizing outside the home more, attending college, and working for suffrage. But the changes were also made possible by industrialization and highly encouraged by the fashion industry.
There is a reason Vogue was founded in 1892. Rapidly changing fashion and cultivating a constant dissatisfaction incentivized people to buy clothing more often. Goody's Lady Book offered women new ideas for bonnets, skirts, corsets, and sleeves every month. Catalogs like Montgomery Ward and Sears began publishing twice-yearly catalogs in the 1890s, promoting new styles ready to wear. To the great joy and profit of the industry, by the early 1900s, people were spending about 14% of their annual income on clothing, compared with just 10% in pre-industrial America.
But people still looked pretty good in clothes. Even a factory-made suit was often tailored at home or locally to get the right fit, and a nice suit could still last a man for a decade or more. Women were conforming to the fashion in vogue, but it was still recognizably feminine, and never strayed too far from the shirt-skirt paradigm. We still took dress seriously, in the sense that fashion, for all its rapid changes and profiteering, offered a usable system that tended toward formality.
Courtesy, respect, and a certain egalitarianism. There was a cultural resistance to the worst predations of the money-grubbing fashion overlords. Notre Dame professor of history, Linda Prisbeski, has carefully documented the phenomenon of the dress doctors, who taught young women the art of dress in the first half of the 20th century.
She wrote, Educating young women in the art of dress was as integral a part of their formal education as the science of housekeeping. High school and college textbooks with titles like The Mode in Dress and Home and Art and Art in Home and Clothing enlightened the young female mind, assuring that garish gauntlets or passé peplums never hampered the future happiness and productivity of educated American women. Shelter and Clothing, a 1914 college textbook written by two women who taught at Columbia, offered this advice.
A home based on the right principles will be simple. No ostentation or living beyond one's means, simplicity and entertainment, and an offering freely of what one has to friends without apology or explanation. Simple furnishings, simple healthful food, simple artistic clothing, all help to simplify life and give the homemakers more time for the family joys and intercourse. So, how did we get from this to this? And I'm sorry to say, it's time to blame the boomers. Now, I want to take it a little easy on them.
As I just showed you, the devolution of dress started at least 100 years before the hippies burned the bras. The flapper dresses of the 20s represented a real rupture in female fashion that shocked and disgusted their uptight Gibson girl mothers. And athleisure wear wasn't invented by Lululemon. Wealthy Americans were donning tennis dresses and golfer pants for lawn parties as far back as the turn of the 20th century. The boomers' parents, men and women who had lived through World War II and Korea, were already embracing a more informal, relaxed style at home.
The wars had forced Americans to simplify fashion, rationing even in space. Some women were inspired to re-tailor their husband's old suits for themselves. And when they came home, men who had spent years in military uniforms still wore suits to work. Think of madmen. But at home and on weekends, casual sportswear started trending. And then came the 60s. This is when the simplification of design turned into what Przewski calls the stupidity of design. Youth culture became a key influence in fashion, and America's post-war prosperity gave the fashion industry the capital to offer young people free-spirited new clothes to express their total rejection of traditional values.
The miniskirt and bikini, which were defining trends in high and low fashion, became symbols of the boomers' rebellion. The clothes were not made with adult female bodies in mind, either. Przewski again. If you take pattern books from the 1950s and the 1960s and you lay them side by side, it's as if every model became a child. You go from this extraordinarily sophisticated look in the 50s, Sophisticated in design, sophisticated in cut, in color, and so worldly, really, to just one decade later, when everyone is sporting what would have been known in another era as a toddler dress, a simple A-line dress.
Boomers rejected the uniform of the man for the uniform of the revolution. So, it's fair to say that the hippies uniformly and rigidly rejected uniformity and rigidity. Resulting in a new market for relaxed, bohemian wear, endless denim, cheap miniskirts, and more. Boomers who didn't conform to the new fashions were square, or uptight establishment types.
Conformist prudes were recognizable by their clothing alone. The great irony, of course, is that as clothing was touted as a form of self-expression, it was actually just another trend embraced by the massive herd of independent minds. And the fashion industry happily responded to the herd's sartorial needs. But the thing with monetizing revolution is you have to keep it going.
Every decade then needs a new revolution to keep the streams of couture cash flowing. In the 1990s, the American apparel space was languishing. Case in point, Levi Strauss noticed a new trend that was yet to be monetized. Casual work attire had begun to spread beyond Silicon Valley. and Hawaii, fueled in part on this growing cultural assumption that relaxed dress codes would lead to happier and more productive employees. So, Levi Strauss mailed a guide to casual business wear to 25,000 American employers.
The pamphlet featured professionals smartly dressed in Dockers khakis, a young Levi brand that had been mostly confined to the golf course. The pitch? Casual Fridays was a free way to boost employee morale without being sloppy. There were also a few thinly-veiled suggestions highly reminiscent of the hippie revolution that formal dress codes were used by corporations to hide inefficiency and incompetence. Casual dress was a symbol of forward-thinking entrepreneurship, success, and creative genius. And it worked. In 1995, 90% of companies had either a full-time or part-time casual dress code, up from just 66% in 1992.
And in 1995, Levi's enjoyed record sales of $6.2 billion, up 10% from just the previous year. By now, though, casual dress has seeped into every private and public space of American life. As the culture fell into deep institutional distrust and eroding communities, that distrust and cynicism has fed a general mood that expectations, whether imposed by a school or church or employers or parents, are inherently oppressive. Schools abandoned their dress codes, social norms around church fits eroded, and celebrities helped drive a shirt-optional message for girls.
A direct line emerged from the boomers' stick-it-to-the-man miniskirts to the F-U-I-dress-for-me extreme sweatpants phenomenon that we see everywhere today. Our clothing betrays a cultural conviction that how I feel has become the most important factor in decisions from where we work, to where we go to school, to how we eat, to how we dress in public. Now, I always like to take clothing trends with a big dose of humor, because I remember as a teenager agonizing over what to wear to school, and feeling like I was really finding my style and crafting my identity as someone unique.
Irreplaceable, and of course, very deep. But we are all, especially perhaps young people, really driven into our fashion choices by fear and desire. Philosopher and anthropologist René Girard makes this point in his theories of memetic desire. The specific looks any individual adopts are imitations of what they see everyone around them doing, and their clothes signal that they belong to a certain group.
The specific look that any individual adopts is an imitation of what we see everyone around us doing. Our clothes signal that we belong to a group. We move more like a starling in a swarm than like black, solitary eagles.
There are two ways that we can look at how we dress, and they both have to do with Adam and Eve. The first is the, wait, I'm naked approach. When they disobeyed God, even before he found them, Adam and Eve grabbed whatever was at hand, and they hid their bodies with disintegrating vegetation. Sound familiar? The primordial hippie hemp dress, an expression of interior disorientation after their radical F.U. to God. This attitude toward what we wear is desperate and scrambling. The fear-driven realization that we are naked, we have nothing to wear.
And the frantic rush to cover ourselves with fast fashion. The fig leaf was the first ready-to-wear flimsy dress a woman ever put on. Now, I don't wear jeans to mass, and I don't wear sweatpants to the grocery store, but I have to ask myself, am I acting in the same way? Am I accumulating one-time wear clothes in order to be seen as a certain kind of person? Am I staring at my 35 shirts in the closet thinking, darn it, I have nothing to wear for LOOPcast this week?
And yes, you'd better believe it. I do. But the yikes, I have nothing to wear is not the last word. In his mercy, in the Genesis story, God provides Adam and Eve with new clothing, this time made from animal skins, to protect them in their exile from paradise.
Later on, Christ himself would be the new garment. St. Paul would write, baptized into union with him, you have all put on Christ as a garment. The white garment received in baptism is a sacramental sign of the new Christian's indelible dignity as a child of God. And now, we don't walk around in our baptismal garments every day. They would not fit us at this point. We set them aside. But we also take every thought captive, including our clothing choices for Christ.
Catholic religious make this choice most obviously with their distinctive habits, a sign of their total gift of self to Christ and his church. But every faithful Christian can take a proportional, not obsessive, approach to how we participate in the cultural trends of our time. Catholic author Anna Kalinowska notes, The daily attire of a Christian, then, is less a continuation of Adam and Eve's fig leaves of mourning, and more a symbol of our restoration. It is a reminder of our baptismal garment in the same way that Every meal is a reminder of the Eucharist.
That leaves a lot of room for variety, for personal taste, the physical demands of our particular vocations and careers, and even the freedom for women to wear pants. But it might just exclude wearing Cookie Monster pants to Walmart.
If you liked this episode, be sure to subscribe to the LOOPcast. We bring you a new episode of The Deep every Thursday at 4 p.m. Eastern.






